We know you pour your heart (and probably too many hours) into your business. You love your customers, especially the loyal ones who keep coming back. So, naturally, you want to reward them! Loyalty discounts, punch cards, “VIP” specials – they seem like a no-brainer. A little thank you, a little incentive to keep them hooked. But what if that sweet discount has a seriously sour aftertaste? What if your generosity is secretly training your customers to only buy when there’s a markdown? Let’s peel back the curtain on the hidden costs of loyalty discounts.
The Allure of the Discount (It’s Strong!)
It feels good to offer a discount, right? You imagine your best customers feeling appreciated. You picture new customers being drawn in by the promise of future savings. Loyalty programs can build community and encourage repeat visits. On the surface, it seems like pure win-win.
The Customer Gets: A tangible reward, a feeling of being special, saved money.
You Get: Repeat business (hopefully!), positive word-of-mouth, data on customer habits.
It sounds perfect. So, what could possibly go wrong? Well, quite a bit, actually.
Hidden Cost #1: The Profit Erosion Avalanche
This is the biggie, the silent budget killer. Every discount you give directly chips away at your profit margin. Let’s say your profit margin on a $10 item is $3 (30%). If you give a loyal customer a 10% discount ($1 off), you’re not just giving away $1 of revenue – you’re giving away 33% of your profit on that sale! That $1 discount means you only made $2 profit instead of $3.
Now, multiply that by every loyal customer, every time they buy. It adds up incredibly fast. And if your margins are thinner than a slice of deli ham? That discount could mean you’re barely breaking even, or even losing money on that “loyal” sale.
Hidden Cost #2: Training “Discount Detectives” Instead of Loyal Fans
Here’s the real psychological trap. Humans are creatures of habit, especially when it comes to saving money. When you consistently offer a discount for loyalty, you’re not just rewarding behavior; you’re actively training your customers to expect it.
Stage 1: “Wow, thanks for the discount! I feel valued!”
Stage 2: “Hmm, I wonder if my loyalty discount applies to this new thing?”
Stage 3: “I’ll only buy it when I can use my discount. I’ll wait.”
Stage 4: “Why isn’t there a discount? I’m loyal! Guess I’ll go somewhere else that appreciates me today.”
Suddenly, your “loyal” customer base transforms into a pack of savvy shoppers conditioned to hold out for the deal. Their loyalty isn’t to your brand or your unique value anymore; it’s to the discount. The second you stop offering it, or if a competitor offers a slightly better deal, they might vanish faster than free samples at a farmers market. You haven’t built loyalty; you’ve built dependency – on lower prices. It’s like training your dog to only sit if you have a treat visible. Without the treat? Blank stare. Or worse, they find someone else with tastier treats.
Hidden Cost #3: Devaluing Your Awesome Stuff
Think about luxury brands. Do Louis Vuitton or Rolex constantly offer loyalty discounts? Nope. Why? Because constant discounting screams, “My stuff isn’t really worth the full price!” When you routinely discount for loyalty, you subtly teach customers that your regular prices are inflated, and the discounted price is the “real” price.
This makes it incredibly hard to ever sell at full price again, even to new customers. Why should they pay $10 when they know your “loyal” customers only pay $9? Your product or service starts looking like a commodity – something bought only on price, not on its unique merits or quality. You worked hard to build something great! Don’t let discounts accidentally tell the world it’s not worth paying full price for.
Hidden Cost #4: The “Loyalty” That Doesn’t Pay the Bills
Let’s be brutally honest: Some customers attracted primarily by discounts are expensive to keep. They might:
Only buy discounted items: Ignoring your full-margin products.
Demand extra service: Because they feel “special,” requiring more staff time and effort for less profit.
Complain more: If the discount isn’t applied perfectly, or if they feel they deserve more.
Have low overall spend: Their total value, even with repeat visits, might be low because they only buy the deeply discounted things.
These aren’t truly loyal, high-value customers; they’re discount chasers. You might be spending significant marketing dollars and operational effort catering to customers who contribute very little to your actual profitability. It’s like throwing a fancy party where most guests only eat the free chips and dip.
Hidden Cost #5: Missing Out on Better Opportunities
The time, energy, and money you pour into managing and funding your loyalty discount program (tracking points, printing cards, setting up systems, eating the cost) could be invested elsewhere! Imagine using those resources to:
Improve your product or service: Making it so good people want to pay full price.
Train your staff: Creating amazing experiences that build real emotional loyalty.
Market to NEW, full-price customers: Expanding your reach.
Create truly unique, non-discount rewards: Experiences or perks that delight without slashing prices.
Simply boost your own salary or business savings!
Okay, So What’s the Alternative? (Don’t Panic!)
Does this mean you should never reward loyal customers? Absolutely not! Building genuine loyalty is crucial. The key is to shift from price-based rewards to value-based appreciation. You want customers loyal to you, not just your discounts. Here’s how:
Focus on Experiences and Exclusivity (The “Cool Factor”):
Early Access: Let loyal customers buy new products or book new services before anyone else. People love feeling “in the know.”
Invite-Only Events: Host special workshops, tastings, or sales just for your best customers. It builds community.
Behind-the-Scenes Peek: Show them how things are made or share stories about your business. Connection builds loyalty.
Personalized Touches: A handwritten thank you note, remembering their name and usual order, or a small freebie they actually love (not just a generic discount) goes miles further than 10% off. “Wow, they remembered I love the lemon cookies! That’s way better than saving 50 cents.”
Offer Non-Monetary Perks (Things That Don’t Slash Profit):
Free Priority Shipping: Costs you less than a blanket discount and is highly valued.
Extended Returns/Exchanges: Builds trust and reduces purchase hesitation.
Complimentary Services: A free gift wrap, a quick consultation, a small add-on service.
“Members-Only” Content: Helpful tips, recipes, or industry insights shared via email or a private group.
Points for Actions, Not Just Spending: Reward engagement – leaving a review, following on social media, referring a friend (who buys at full price!).
Reframe “Loyalty” Programs (Make Them About Recognition, Not Just Redemption):
Tiered Programs: Offer increasingly valuable non-discount perks at higher tiers (e.g., Bronze: Free shipping, Silver: + Monthly freebie, Gold: + Early access + Event invites). The top tiers become aspirational.
Surprise & Delight: Randomly upgrade a loyal customer’s purchase, throw in an unexpected extra, or send a small gift on their birthday. Unpredictable rewards create excitement and genuine goodwill. “Finding that free fancy coffee upgrade felt like winning a tiny lottery, not just cashing in a punch card.”
Community Building: Create a space (online or in-store) where your loyal customers can connect with each other and with you. Loyalty to the community around your brand is powerful.
Be Strategic & Selective with Discounts:
Time-Limited Offers: Use discounts sparingly for specific goals – clearing slow inventory, boosting sales during a genuinely slow period, attracting new customers (with a clear end date!).
Targeted Discounts: Offer a discount on a specific item you want to promote, not a blanket percentage off everything.
Focus on Acquisition First: Give the best discounts to new customers as an incentive to try you. Your goal with loyal customers is to move them away from needing discounts.
Make it Special, Not Expected: Frame it as a rare “Thank You Celebration” or a “Flash Appreciation Sale,” not a routine entitlement. The key is breaking the conditioning that “loyalty = automatic discount.”
The Punchline (Literally)
Loyalty discounts can be like that friend who always insists on splitting the bill but conveniently forgets their wallet when it’s the expensive cocktails round. They seem fair at first, but you often end up paying more than your share for diminishing returns. Don’t let your generosity train your customers to only value your business when it’s on sale.
Building real loyalty isn’t about constantly cutting prices; it’s about constantly adding value. Shift your focus from the discount to the delight. Reward your best customers with recognition, exclusivity, and experiences that make them feel genuinely appreciated and connected to your brand. This builds customers who are loyal to you, not just your markdowns, and that’s the kind of loyalty that truly pays off – for your customers and your bottom line.
It’s time to break the discount cycle and build a business people love at any price!
Join my FREE Facebook group for small business owners. https://www.facebook.com/groups/scaleorsellgroup
Hi, I’m Heather.
I help people buy, scale, and sell businesses. Think of me as your “anti-corporate” guide to ownership.
If you like blunt truths, dry humor, and leaders who’d rather light a fire than follow a script… let’s talk.
Started my first company at 23.
Now have 5.
Learned 1,000,037 hard-earned lessons so you can skip the trial-and-error phase.
Current obsessions:
✅ Turning “boring” industries into wealth-building machines
✅ Helping ambitious people escape soul-crushing corporate cultures
✅ Proving you don’t need an Ivy League MBA to win at business
Let’s connect if:
-You want to own your future, not rent it
-You’ve ever been told you’re “too much” for corporate America
-If you are ready to work on your business not in your business.
Grab my FREE ebook Productize & Scale https://links.buy-scale-sell.com/widget/form/gekvv1rcvamInQC5NTwV