Starting a business is hard. You’re wearing a dozen hats, from CEO to janitor, and every customer complaint feels like a personal attack. You lie awake at night wondering, “Did I do enough? Will they be happy? Why is this so complicated?”
What if there was a way to make it… simpler? Not easy, mind you—running a business is never easy—but simpler. A way to dramatically reduce the drama, the complaints, and the endless back-and-forth with customers.
There is. And it all comes down to one powerful concept: The Binary Outcome Business.
This might sound like a fancy term from a business textbook, but stick with me. It’s the simplest idea you’ll hear all week, and it might just change the kind of business you decide to start or the services you choose to offer.
What in the World is a “Binary Outcome” Business?
In plain English, a “binary outcome” means there are only two possible results. On or off. Yes or no. Done or not done.
A binary outcome business is one where your service has a very clear, undeniable, and easy-to-measure finish line. The customer’s need is either completely satisfied, or it isn’t. There’s very little room for opinion, taste, or lengthy debates about shades of beige.
Let’s look at the examples from the title, because they perfectly illustrate the difference.
The Champion of Binary Outcomes: Stump Grinding
Imagine you’re a stump grinder. A customer calls you and says, “There’s an ugly tree stump in my backyard.” You show up with your big, noisy machine. You turn it on. A cloud of wood chips flies. Twenty minutes later, the stump is gone, replaced by a pile of fresh mulch.
The outcome is binary.
Before: Stump.
After: No Stump.
The customer looks out the window and thinks, “Yep. The stump is gone. Amazing.” They are thrilled. The problem that has been annoying them for months has vanished. You get a five-star review that says, “Hired John to grind a stump. It’s gone! Fast and professional. 5 stars!”
There is no debate. The stump is not mostly gone. It is gone. The job is a clear success.
The Quicksand of subjectivity: House Painting
Now, let’s look at our friend, the house painter. A customer hires them to paint their living room “Agreeable Gray.”
Sounds straightforward, right? Wrong.
The outcome is not binary. It’s a swirling vortex of subjectivity.
“You missed a spot.” (A never-ending claim.)
“Is this the right shade? It looks a little blue to me.” (It’s the shade you agreed on.)
“How many layers of primer did you use? Are you sure that’s enough?” (The customer suddenly becomes a paint chemist.)
“When will you be done? We have guests coming tomorrow!” (The timeline is always a pressure cooker.)
The painter can do a technically perfect job, but the customer might still be unhappy because the light hits the wall at 4 PM in a way they don’t like. The job is never just “done.” It’s “done, but…”
See the difference? One business has a clear on/off switch. The other has a dimmer switch that the customer keeps fiddling with forever.
Why Your Brain (And Your Business) Loves Binary Outcomes
So, why does this matter? Because binary outcomes make every part of your business easier, more profitable, and far less stressful.
1. Reviews and Referrals Become Almost Automatic
People leave reviews for two main reasons: they are extremely happy, or they are extremely angry. A binary outcome business is a review-generating machine because it creates extreme satisfaction by completely solving a clear, tangible problem.
When you completely erase a customer’s pain point—like a stump, a leaky faucet, or a pile of junk in their garage—the feeling of relief is powerful and immediate. That feeling translates directly into a glowing five-star review and a enthusiastic referral to their neighbor.
With a subjective service, even a happy customer might just think, “Well, they did a good job,” and move on with their life. The “wow” factor is muted. With a binary outcome, the “wow” is built-in.
2. Customer Communication is Crystal Clear
In a stump grinding business, the sales conversation is simple.
Customer: “I have a stump.”
You: “I remove stumps. It costs $X.”
Customer: “Great. When can you come?”
In a painting or custom home building business, the conversation is a black hole for your time.
Customer: “I want my house painted.” (Then follows 47 emails about color choices, paint brands, sheen levels, trim details, and a daily schedule that changes twice.)
Binary outcomes set clear expectations from the very beginning. Everyone agrees on what “done” looks like, because “done” is obvious.
3. You Spend Less Time on “Damage Control”
Think about the mental energy and time you waste managing customer anxiety, tweaking things to their personal taste, or defending your process. In a binary business, you don’t have a “process” to defend. You have a result to deliver.
The stump is gone. The junk is hauled away. The lock is installed. The toilet is unclogged.
There’s no arguing with the result. This frees up your mind to focus on what actually matters: finding the next customer and doing the job efficiently.
Expanding the Concept: E-Commerce vs. Home Building
Let’s go bigger with the other example from the title. This really drives the point home.
The Binary Outcome King: E-commerce
You sell a specific, well-photographed widget on your website. A customer clicks “buy.” You pack the widget in a box and ship it.
The outcome is beautifully binary.
Before: Customer does not have the widget.
After: Customer has the widget.
The review is simple: “Received my widget, it works great, shipping was fast. 5 stars!”
The transaction is clean. The outcome is undeniable. They either got the widget or they didn’t. The widget either works as described or it doesn’t. There’s no, “I thought the widget would make me feel happier on a Tuesday,” or “The emotional resonance of this widget isn’t what I envisioned.”
The Subjectivity Nightmare: Custom Home Building
Now, put yourself in the shoes of a custom home builder. You are building the single most expensive and personal thing a family will ever own. Their emotions, their marriage, and their life savings are all tied up in this project.
The outcome is the opposite of binary. It’s a multi-year journey through a forest of opinions, changing minds, and sky-high expectations.
“This isn’t what I wanted!” (Even though they approved the plans.)
“Hurry up and finish!” (While also demanding 17 change orders.)
“Why is this outlet different from the one in the drawing?”
“We saw this new countertop on HGTV, can we change it?”
The builder can build a structurally perfect, beautiful house, and the customers can still be unhappy because the journey was stressful. The outcome isn’t just the house; it’s the entire experience of building it. There is no clear “win.” It’s always a negotiation.
Is Your Business (Or Your New Idea) Binary?
Okay, so you’re sold on the idea. How can you apply this to your own situation? Whether you’re just starting out or thinking of adding a new service to your existing business, ask yourself these questions:
The “Binary Outcome” Test:
The “Before and After” Test: Can you easily take a “before” picture and an “after” picture that clearly show the job is complete? (Stump/no stump, dirty driveway/clean driveway, old lock/new lock). If yes, that’s a great sign.
The “Customer Opinion” Test: Once the job is done, is the result based mostly on fact or mostly on feeling? If a customer can’t really argue with the fact (“the stump is gone”), you’re in binary territory. If it’s about a feeling (“the room doesn’t feel cozy”), you’re in subjective territory.
The “Review” Test: Imagine the perfect 5-star review for this service. Is it short, simple, and focused on a solved problem? Or is it a long, gushing paragraph about your amazing personality and how you held their hand through a difficult process? The former is binary; the latter is not.
Examples of Binary Outcome Businesses:
Junk Removal
Gutter Cleaning
Window Washing
Power Washing
Lawn Mowing/Landscaping (basic maintenance)
Locksmithing
Pest Control
Appliance Repair (fixed/not fixed)
Simple E-commerce (selling specific, tangible products)
Examples of Subjective (Non-Binary) Businesses:
Interior Design
Marketing and Advertising Agencies (“Did this ad feel right?”)
Consulting
Web Design (“Can you just make it pop more?”)
Personal Training (results are slow and based on client effort)
Wedding Photography (highly emotional and based on taste)
What If Your Business Isn’t Binary? Should You Panic?
No! Not at all. The world needs amazing painters, visionary home builders, and brilliant designers. These businesses can be incredibly profitable and fulfilling.
The point of this article isn’t to say you should only start binary businesses. The point is to make you think strategically about the kind of business you’re getting into.
If you’re in a subjective business, you need to be aware of the challenges from day one. Your success will depend less on a simple result and more on your ability to:
Manage Expectations: You need to be a master of communication and set crystal-clear boundaries.
Educate the Customer: Explain your process in detail so they understand the “why” behind your actions.
Build a Strong Brand: People hire you for your taste and your reputation, not just for a simple task.
Have Thicker Skin: You will deal with more feedback, some of it unfair. You have to be prepared for that.
Knowing that you’re in a subjective business allows you to build your systems and your mindset to handle that reality.
But if you’re a new entrepreneur, or if you’re feeling burned out by constant customer management, pivoting towards a more binary offering can be a game-changer. It’s a way to simplify your operations, supercharge your marketing through reviews, and actually enjoy the work you do without the constant emotional rollercoaster.
The Bottom Line: Choose Your Battle
Starting a business is a battle. You’re battling competitors, your cash flow, and your own doubts. A binary outcome business allows you to fight on a clear, defined battlefield where the rules of victory are simple.
You solve a specific, tangible problem. The customer is happy. You get a great review. You get a referral. You get paid. You move on to the next job with your sanity intact.
It’s a straightforward, profitable, and sustainable way to build a business. So, before you jump into that next venture, ask yourself: “Is the outcome binary?” Your future self, relaxing after a day of clear wins and five-star reviews, will thank you for it.
Grab my book! https://amzn.to/45Cm2ky
Hi, I’m Heather.
Let me help you scale your Utah $1M+ biz to $20M+
My credentials:
- Built & sold Queen of Wraps (yep, that’s my face on the side of I-15)
- Learned 1,769,230+ lessons so you skip trial-and-error
- Zero Ivy MBA (just pioneer grit + market-tested tactics)
Let’s talk if you’re:
- Ready to make your ‘good’ business a GREAT business
- Hitting $1M+ and knowing you’re built for more
- Have 10+ employees that need to see your vision
Subscribe to my YouTube https://www.youtube.com/@Buy-Scale-Sell